Ex-Premier League referee explains why VAR was RIGHT in Man City vs Liverpool controversy

View 2 Images

Mark Halsey insists that referee Craig Pawson 'had no choice' but to disallow what would have been Manchester City 's third goal during the dramatic finale of their 2-1 win over Liverpool on Sunday , despite a significant backlash to the decision.

Liverpool were chasing the game after two goals in nine minutes from Bernardo Silva and Erling Haaland had nudged City into the ascendancy and sent Alisson up for a corner. City broke and as a long-range effort from Rayan Cherki trickled towards the goal, Dominik Szoboszlai pulled Haaland back to prevent him getting to the ball. The Norwegian striker retaliated before both lost their footing just before the ball crossed the line.

But although Pawson chose to allow the goal to stand after playing advantage for Szoboszlai's foul on Haaland, VAR intervened and recommended a review, which led to the decision being overturned and a red card being issued to the Liverpool midfielder.

Fans and pundits alike have slammed the decision but Halsey, who spent years refereeing in the Premier League , has explained why Pawson was right to change his mind.

"Craig Pawson had no choice but to rule out what would have been Manchester City’s third goal against Liverpool," Halsey wrote in The Sun . "Credit to Craig, he was waiting to see what happened when Rayan Cherki sent the ball towards an unguarded net in stoppage time with City 2-1 up.

"Dominik Szoboszlai pulls Erling Haaland back but Craig waits to see if Haaland can still get to the ball. That doesn’t happen, so when Haaland then pulls Szoboszlai back, that is stopping the Liverpool player from preventing the ball from going into the net.

"No advantage had been signalled. So once VAR John Brooks calls Craig across he has no choice – he has got to look at the first offence, the denial of a goal-scoring opportunity.

"Craig was correct in law. People will be saying, ‘Why didn’t he just give the goal?’. But Haaland’s pull-back stopped the Liverpool player from clearing the ball."

View 2 Images

While Halsey commended Pawson for following the laws of the game, others have questioned the outcome. Gary Neville , commentating for Sky Sports , said after the VAR call: "Talk about a killjoy. They have just killed one of the great moments of the season."

Haaland himself sympathised with Szoboszlai but said he understood why Pawson had to follow the rules, telling Sky Sports: "'I think for me of course the referee has to follow the rules.

"This will give him three games, I feel bad for him, he gets three games, just give the goal don't give the red card.

"(But) it's the rules so this is how it is. In the end Cherki passed me the ball so he scores, so that's just how it is."

Sky has slashed the price of its Essential TV and Sky Sports bundle ahead of the 2025/26 season, saving members £336 and offering more than 1,400 live matches across the Premier League, EFL and more.