Newcastle United vs Manchester United: How Carrick counters Howe’s high press

Michael Carrick takes Manchester United to St. James’ Park on Wednesday for a Premier League meeting with Eddie Howe’s Newcastle United.

United travel with their eyes set on Champions League football, while Newcastle are trying to halt a poor run of domestic form. The Red Devils stretched their unbeaten run to seven matches on Sunday, coming from behind to beat Crystal Palace 2-1 and moving up to third place.

Meanwhile, the Magpies were beaten 3-2 at home by Everton and have just one win in their last seven league outings.

The key change since Carrick stepped in has been United’s structure out of possession. A traditional 4-2-3-1 has helped the Old Trafford club pick their moments to press on specific opposition triggers.

It also keeps Casemiro and Kobbie Mainoo close to the centre-backs, while allowing Bruno Fernandes to drift into pockets of space and link attacks. This shape can switch into a compact low block when needed, with Matheus Cunha and Amad staying narrow and tracking back to protect the back four.

In possession, width is created through Diogo Dalot , which allows Fernandes, Mainoo, and Casemiro to stay tight to each other and combine quickly through the centre. From there, they look to release Bryan Mbeumo or Benjamin Sesko in behind the last line of defence.

Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire, however, were both forced off against Palace, so United will have to adjust their build-up play in the first phase if either is unavailable.

On the other hand, Newcastle rely on Tino Livramento’s aggressive support when he pushes high up the pitch from full-back positions. They also require Jacob Ramsey and Lewis Miley’s energy from deep in midfield to press, recover, and then transition again.

All three, however, will likely be out, which alters how the North East club operate in the half-spaces. Furthermore, the Everton defeat showed how quickly things can fall apart for the Toon Army when focus drops after big moments.

United will, therefore, believe they can make the game about punishing any individual error. The Geordies, however, will back themselves if they can box United in early with Nick Woltemade and Joelinton, thus baiting the likes of Leny Yoro and Ayden Heaven into hurried clearances.

Finally, they will look to keep the pressure on and control the tempo and rhythm through Sandro Tonali , without getting caught on the break.

Casemiro and Mainoo holding their shape means that Newcastle will be pushed out wide and forced to cross through Kieran Trippier. One through ball from Tonali can put Anthony Gordon into a one-v-one situation if United’s double pivot becomes disconnected, though.

Moreover, Newcastle will attempt to isolate Dalot in a touchline duel. Notably, Harvey Barnes or Anthony Elanga will be tasked with making the Portuguese international play a risky pass in-field.

Conversely, United will create overloads through Noussair Mazraoui on the left, then switch play quickly into the right channel for Amad and Mbeumo to drive forward—a move that could pull Newcastle’s high press out of shape. United have been scoring from good deliveries into the box and well-timed runs as of late, while Newcastle conceded from a corner on Sunday and then lost concentration right after equalising.

How both sides handle set-pieces and dead ball situations, therefore, could decide proceedings in the final analysis. If United can keep the crowd quiet early on, Carrick’s side should find space as Newcastle commit bodies forward.

However, if Newcastle score first, St. James’ Park can turn the match into a dogfight.

Featured image Carl Recine via Getty Images

The Peoples Person has been one of the world’s leading Man United news sites for over a decade. Follow us on Bluesky: @peoplesperson.bsky.social